In an ambitious move during the 2016 NFL color rush initiative, the Miami Dolphins decided to experiment with their traditional color scheme by introducing a lighter, more vibrant shade of orange into their game-day wear. This decision led to a strikingly different set of uniforms, featuring light orange jerseys and pants that were a departure from their usual attire.
Christian D’Andrea of For The Win did not hold back in his assessment of these uniforms, dubbing them the “worst jersey in franchise history.” According to D’Andrea, while the intent to innovate was clear, the execution fell short of expectations.
He remarked, “Orange is a tough look to pull off. Miami kinda/sorta did it earlier in the 2000s thanks to the expressive drop shadows in its numbering.
This kit doesn’t have that kind of flavor. It just feels like something you’d see at Marshall’s or Ross Dress for Less.”
The Dolphins’ foray into this bold color choice highlights the inherent risks and potential backlash when teams attempt to deviate from their traditional palette. Despite the criticism, the move represents a willingness to explore new identities and stand out during the color rush games, a sentiment that not all teams embraced as eagerly.
The reaction to the Dolphins’ orange color rush jerseys being labeled as the worst in the franchise’s history is mixed. While some agree with D’Andrea’s harsh critique, others commend the team for stepping outside the norm and experimenting with a color that is undoubtedly a significant part of their logo and identity.
It’s worth noting that the Dolphins have previously worn orange jerseys, albeit in a darker, more subdued shade. This lighter version of orange, while not universally loved, signifies the team’s attempt at reinvigorating their image and engaging with the spirit of the NFL color rush series.
The Dolphins’ endeavors during this period serve as a reminder of the challenges teams face when trying to balance tradition with innovation. Though not everyone was a fan of the 2016 color rush experiment, it demonstrated the team’s ambition to differentiate themselves, even if the results didn’t resonate with all fans. As D’Andrea pointed out, when it comes to alternate jerseys, the outcome could always be more divisive—just ask fans of the Jaguars or Steelers.