As we hit the midway point of this NFL season, it’s a perfect time to dive into some expert predictions for how the playoff picture might shape up. An assembly of 27 NFL Network and NFL.com analysts recently weighed in, voting on the eight AFC and NFC division winners and the six coveted wild-card spots. Among these experts, former NFL quarterback David Carr set the boldest course, placing his bets on the Miami Dolphins snagging one of those elusive wild-card slots despite nursing a tough 2-6 record.
Carr, a former first overall pick in the 2002 NFL Draft by the Houston Texans and a Super Bowl XLVI champion with the New York Giants, isn’t shy about making daring calls. His belief in Miami’s playoff potential harks back to underdog stories like the 2020 Washington Football Team and the 2022 Jacksonville Jaguars, both teams that defied early-season struggles to secure playoff berths with similar 2-6 starts.
The analysts’ breakdown for wild-card slots revealed a solid consensus for some teams while leaving room for surprises. The Los Angeles Chargers, nabbing 57 votes, and the Pittsburgh Steelers, just one vote shy, led the pack as the most popular wild-card picks. However, Carr stands alone in his optimism for the Dolphins, voting them alongside heavyweights like the Buffalo Bills, Baltimore Ravens, Houston Texans, and Kansas City Chiefs as division champs, and the Chargers and Cincinnati Bengals as fellow wild-card contenders.
Additional teams caught the analysts’ eyes for potential playoff runs, but the Dolphins aren’t wandering alone in the dark horse slot. Sharing the stage with them are the New York Jets, currently sitting at 3-6, who also received one vote—this one from Dan Parr. With pivotal matchups against the Dolphins in weeks 14 and 18, the Jets could significantly alter the landscape as they try to claw their way into the playoffs.
Here, we find ourselves questioning: can Carr’s faith in Miami spark a resurgence reminiscent of those past underdog success stories, or will the Dolphins tumble under the weight of their early missteps? One thing’s for sure: the back half of the NFL season holds plenty of intrigue and potential for unexpected twists. Stay glued, because in football, anything can happen.
