In his debut season, Joey Porter Jr. of the Pittsburgh Steelers has already made waves, establishing himself as a formidable presence in the team’s secondary. Recently, when asked to weigh in on who he believes are the top cornerbacks in the NFL, Porter provided a list that sparked conversations, notably for its exclusions as much as for its inclusions.
During a discussion with NFL insider Jordan Schultz, Porter named his picks, omitting highly acclaimed corners such as Sauce Gardner and Jalen Ramsey from his list. His selections not only highlight his respect for his peers but also subtly indicate the competitive nature and individual perspectives inherent in professional sports.
Porter’s top choices for the league’s best cornerbacks are as follows:
He began by acknowledging the breadth of talent, saying, “There’s a lot of corners.” His list started with L’Jarius Sneed and Trent McDuffie, both praised for their contributions to the Kansas City Chiefs’ defensive prowess.
Jaylon Johnson of the Chicago Bears was another name mentioned, with Porter recognizing him as a formidable competitor, stating, “I think he’s a dog.” The inclusion of Patrick Surtain was almost a given based on the consensus around Surtain’s abilities, with Porter remarking, “Surtain’s like that already.”
Notably, Porter didn’t shy away from including himself among the elite, showcasing a confident, if unsurprising, self-endorsement.
These selections have sparked debate, particularly among those analyzing the dynamics of the NFL’s cornerback hierarchy. For example, Patrick Surtain, a 2023 Pro Bowler, is universally regarded as one of the position’s top talents. Meanwhile, Jaylon Johnson, who secured a $76 million extension with the Bears, has proven his worth on the field, further cementing his status as a top player with his Pro Bowl selection this year.
However, discussions amongst fans and pundits alike tend to circle back to the conspicuous absence of Sauce Gardner and Jalen Ramsey from Porter’s list. Gardner, the 2022 Defensive Rookie of the Year, has had a meteoric rise with two first-team All-Pro selections in as many seasons, thanks to his unparalleled coverage skills and league-leading pass deflections during his debut year with the New York Jets. Ramsey, despite an injury-shortened season with the Miami Dolphins, remains a key figure in conversations about the league’s elite, bringing a blend of coverage skills and unmatched physicality to the table even as he advances in his career.
The subjective nature of “top” lists in sports is nothing new, yet Porter’s picks offer a unique glimpse into the competitive and diverse landscape of NFL cornerbacks. As debates continue over who genuinely deserves to be ranked among the best, it’s clear that the conversation around the league’s top talent — much like the game itself — is always evolving. Who do you think ranks among today’s best cornerbacks in the NFL?