The Miami Dolphins, a surprising contender in the AFC, are rumored to be considering a significant move this offseason by potentially signing free agent quarterback Ryan Tannehill, who carries a hefty $196 million price tag. Sources indicate that Tannehill, a familiar face for the Dolphins, could be brought back to the team mainly as a backup to provide depth behind starting QB Tua Tagovailoa. With the current backup options being Mike White and Skylar Thompson, Tannehill’s experience would be a valuable asset.
Drafted eighth overall by the Dolphins in 2012, Tannehill served as the team’s starter until 2018 before moving on to the Tennessee Titans, where he has played for the past four seasons. Despite the expectation that his days as a regular starter may be winding down, Tannehill’s potential return to Miami—where he made 151 starts—offers a seasoned option to the team’s quarterback lineup.
Tannehill’s familiarity with the Dolphins’ system, despite the numerous changes since his departure, including the appointment of Mike McDaniel as the head coach, is seen as a positive. Though likely aiming for a one-year contract before considering retirement, Tannehill’s acquisition wouldn’t significantly impact Miami’s salary cap, which currently stands at $1.89 million.
At 64.3% career completion rate with an 81-70 win-loss record, and a playoff record of 2-3, Tannehill brings a blend of reliability and experience. His 2020 season, in particular, showcased his ability to excel with a strong receiving corps, throwing for 3,819 yards and 33 touchdowns. Now, with the prospect of connecting with Miami’s talented receivers like Tyreek Hill, Jaylen Waddle, and Odell Beckham Jr., Tannehill could once again thrive, even in a backup role.
The 2023 season saw a decrease in Tannehill’s on-field presence due to the rise of Will Levis as the starter on his team, highlighting a challenging year. Nonetheless, Tannehill managed 4,152 passing yards and 17 touchdowns over the last two seasons, underscoring his ability to contribute meaningfully despite injuries.
Besides the Dolphins, Tannehill’s wealth of experience could make him an attractive option for other teams like the New Orleans Saints, to support Derek Carr, or the Carolina Panthers, potentially stepping in if Bryce Young struggles. The Dallas Cowboys could also see him as a temporary solution amidst uncertainties surrounding Dak Prescott’s future with the team.
As the Dolphins aim to finalize a deal with Tannehill, his prospective return to Miami not only sparks excitement about what he could bring to the team’s dynamic offense but also raises questions about the broader impacts on the Dolphins’ strategies and other QB-needy teams’ plans this offseason.